July 2025 - May 2026: NCAA Senate Bill Saga
By Michael Alvord · · How we write and fact-check
NCAA Sports is in a bit of a crisis right now, but it's not because people aren't trying to save it, it's because TV networks own it.
Pay Like a Champion Today: Why College Sports’ Future Depends on Balanced Revenue Sharing
When fans pack into Beaver Stadium or flood Austin’s Sixth Street after a win, they see the biggest names in college sports: football, basketball, maybe baseball. But behind the headline sports, hundreds of non-revenue athletes like swimmers, runners, and gymnasts are quietly facing an uncertain future.
As of July 1, 2025, college athletic departments may pay student-athletes directly, under a new $20.5 million annual cap established by a landmark legal settlement. It’s the next step after name, image, and likeness (NIL) rights opened the door for student-athlete compensation.
Athletic directors now face hard choices: fund top-tier programs, comply with Title IX, and keep non-revenue sports alive. While paying athletes is a long-overdue shift, a revenue-sharing system that neglects smaller sports would do long-term harm to both college athletics and campus life.
College sports aren’t just minor-league development systems. They build community and opportunity. Athletic departments must commit to equitable revenue-sharing policies that protect all sports, not just the ones that sell out arenas.
The Money Math Athletic Directors Can’t Ignore
At most major universities, football and men’s basketball account for the majority of athletic revenue. Yet those programs rely on a full athletic department infrastructure, including non-revenue sports that contribute to campus diversity and Olympic development.
Texas Tech, for example, reported in 2015 that its track and field and cross-country programs lost nearly $3.9 million annually, a pattern that continues across the country. With the new revenue-sharing limit in place, schools could feel pressure to shrink rosters, cut scholarships, or eliminate smaller teams.
But cutting non-revenue sports doesn’t just affect balance sheets. It hurts long-term alumni support and the school's reputation.
Why Non-Revenue Sports Still Matter
According to NCAA data, non-revenue sport athletes graduate at higher rates than revenue-sport athletes. Those same athletes often return as donors and ambassadors. A 2023 Council for Advancement and Support of Education (CASE) study found non-revenue athletes are 18% more likely to donate to their alma mater within five years of graduation compared with revenue-sport athletes.
From Olympic medals to community goodwill, these programs provide tangible value beyond ticket sales. Departments that protect non-revenue sports aren’t preserving tradition; they’re investing in future growth.
Can Departments Afford Balance?
Some athletic leaders argue that the $20.5 million cap leaves no room for non-revenue sports. But there are practical options:
- Launch non-revenue sports endowments through targeted fundraising.
- Prioritize athlete support over facility upgrades.
- Expand NIL opportunities to smaller-sport athletes through collective partnerships.
Schools like Texas A&M have already adjusted rosters ahead of the change, according to the Texas Tribune. But departments that take proactive steps now can avoid permanent cuts later.
A Choice for Athletic Department Leaders
Athletic departments have adapted to change before, from Title IX to NIL. The new revenue-sharing model is the next step.
Department leaders must decide whether to treat this moment as a financial problem or a leadership opportunity. Clear, balanced revenue-sharing policies that preserve non-revenue sports are not just ethical, they’re smart business.
The future of college athletics depends on thoughtful decisions today.
The Title IX Balancing Act
Title IX doesn’t just apply to scholarships; it covers all aspects of gender equity in athletics, including pay. If athletic departments choose to funnel the majority of the $20.5 million pool toward male-dominated sports like football and men’s basketball, they could risk violating federal law.
Recent rulings have clarified that proportional investment must still be maintained across men’s and women’s programs. In other words, a football-centric pay model isn’t just inequitable; it could be illegal.
To avoid lawsuits and federal scrutiny, departments must build transparent, proportional compensation structures that reflect the diversity of their athletic programs, including women's non-revenue sports like gymnastics, rowing, and cross-country.
Olympic Implications: A Pipeline at Risk
Non-revenue college sports don’t just serve campuses; they serve the country. According to the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee, nearly 80% of Team USA athletes in recent Summer Olympics competed in college athletics. Many of those athletes come from NCAA programs that don’t turn a profit: track and field, swimming, wrestling, and more.
If schools cut rosters or eliminate teams to redirect funds toward marquee sports, the pipeline that feeds Olympic development could shrink. That doesn’t just affect medal counts; it affects national pride, international standing, and the accessibility of Olympic dreams for athletes of all socioeconomic backgrounds.
Keeping these programs alive isn’t just good for schools; it’s good for the country.
Alumni, Identity, and the Long Game
Revenue sports might generate the biggest headlines, but non-revenue athletes often generate deeper alumni ties. Many former athletes in sports like swimming, tennis, or golf return as donors, mentors, and institutional supporters, even if their competitions drew fewer fans. Athletic identity shapes school identity. A university that supports only the most profitable programs risks alienating the very communities, alumni, students, and local families that give its brand long-term strength.
In contrast, departments that protect non-revenue programs send a clear message: all athletes matter here. That kind of leadership builds loyalty, not just wins.
May 2026 Update
Nearly a year after the implementation of the $20.5 million revenue-sharing model, concerns about the future of college athletics have only intensified. In May 2026, Senators Ted Cruz (R-Texas) and Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.) introduced the bipartisan Protect College Sports Act, a proposal to bring greater structure to an increasingly unstable college sports landscape.
Cruz, who chairs the Senate Commerce Committee, has become one of the leading voices in Congress on college sports reform. He argues that the current system has created an environment of unrestricted transfers, escalating NIL spending, and ongoing legal battles that have weakened the NCAA's ability to govern college athletics.
The proposed legislation would place new restrictions on athlete transfers, strengthen oversight of NIL agreements, and create a College Sports Commission to enforce national rules. Supporters argue these changes would reduce what many athletic directors describe as a "free agency" environment, in which athletes can transfer frequently and schools compete through increasingly aggressive NIL spending.
While much of the public discussion has focused on football and men's basketball, the legislation could have significant implications for non-revenue sports. If NIL spending and athlete compensation are more closely regulated, athletic departments may face less pressure to direct resources exclusively to revenue-generating programs. At the same time, critics argue that limiting athletes' earning opportunities could create new legal challenges and further uncertainty.
The proposal highlights a reality that has become increasingly clear since revenue sharing began: college athletics is still searching for a sustainable model. Whether through athletic department leadership, NCAA governance, or federal legislation, the debate remains the same: How can colleges fairly compensate athletes while preserving opportunities for the swimmers, runners, gymnasts, wrestlers, and other competitors who form the foundation of collegiate athletics?
As lawmakers, universities, and athletic leaders continue to debate the future of college sports, one thing remains certain: the decisions made today will shape not only the future of football and basketball but also the survival of the non-revenue programs that contribute to the educational, cultural, and Olympic mission of college athletics.
The Broadcasting Question Still Looms
While much of the debate surrounding revenue sharing has focused on athlete compensation, another challenge remains unresolved: the growing gap in television revenue between college athletics' biggest and smallest programs.
In May 2026, Cruz and Cantwell included provisions in the proposed Protect College Sports Act that would allow schools and conferences to pool certain media rights under federal antitrust protections. Supporters believe a broader media-rights structure could generate additional revenue and create new funding opportunities for women's athletics, Olympic sports, and other non-revenue programs.
The proposal reflects a growing concern among lawmakers and athletic administrators that the current television model increasingly concentrates wealth among a small group of power conferences. The SEC and Big Ten continue to benefit from massive broadcasting contracts worth billions of dollars, while many smaller conferences struggle to keep pace financially.
Critics of the proposal argue that the legislation does little to solve the underlying imbalance. Power conferences have shown little interest in sharing portions of their lucrative television revenue, and existing long-term media contracts remain firmly in place. As a result, the divide between college athletics' wealthiest programs and everyone else may continue to widen.
For non-revenue sports, the broadcasting debate is about more than television dollars. It is about whether the financial growth of college athletics can be shared broadly enough to preserve opportunities for athletes across all sports. Without a sustainable solution, schools may continue facing pressure to prioritize the programs that generate the most revenue while reducing investment in the teams that help define the educational and developmental mission of college athletics.
Looking Ahead: Reform or More Uncertainty?
Whether the Protect College Sports Act becomes law remains unclear. While the bill has attracted bipartisan support from lawmakers such as Ted Cruz and Maria Cantwell, significant obstacles remain. Athlete advocacy groups have criticized provisions that would limit transfers and NIL opportunities, while some legal experts question whether Congress should grant the NCAA and conferences additional protections from future lawsuits. At the same time, powerful conferences such as the SEC and Big Ten may resist proposals that could affect their control over media rights and television revenue.
For those reasons, many observers view the legislation as an uphill battle. Even if portions of the bill gain support, the final version could look very different from the proposal introduced in 2026.
Yet the bill's introduction reveals something important: leaders across college athletics increasingly agree that the current system is unsustainable. The combination of NIL, revenue sharing, conference realignment, transfer portal movement, and growing financial disparities has created uncertainty for athletes, universities, and fans alike.
The question is no longer whether college athletics will change. It already has. The real question is what kind of system will emerge from this period of transformation.
As policymakers, athletic directors, and university leaders search for answers, they should remember that the future of college sports is bigger than football television contracts or basketball tournament revenue. It also includes the runners, swimmers, wrestlers, gymnasts, golfers, tennis players, and countless other student-athletes whose opportunities depend on the decisions being made today.
If reform is coming, success should not be measured solely by how much money college athletics generates. It should be measured by whether the system continues to provide opportunities for all athletes, regardless of the sport they play.