Rid the Auto-Bid
By Michael Alvord · · How we write and fact-check
Why the conference champion auto-bid is hurting the playoffs
Who's at Fault? The ACC, duh.
The ACC could miss the playoffs entirely if Duke beats Virginia, Saturday night. The rules state that there are guaranteed playoff spots for the five highest-ranked conference champions. They never specified any specific conference. If Duke (7-5) wins the ACC, the next two highest-ranked conference champions would be the winner of the American between North Texas and Tulane, and the Sun Belt champion, James Madison. We would have a playoff field consisting of two guaranteed blowouts in the first round. That sucks. I’m not a cynic, and I’m not trying to be an asshole, but does that sound fun to any of y’all? When they decided to expand the playoffs, they never saw this as a possibility. A power conference champion missing the playoffs, but of course, if there was a conference to expose how flawed this selection system is, it was always going to be the ACC. Let’s say this happens, we’d have a first round that could look like this:
- JMU @ Oregon
- North Texas/Tulane @ Texas A&M
- Alabama @ Ole Miss
- Notre Dame @ Oklahoma
How excited are you to watch the James Madison Dukes take on the Oregon Ducks in Eugene? Or Tulane going to College Station, maybe even a little in-state matchup for North Texas and the Aggies. Isn’t it so exciting that of the three G5 teams that can make the playoffs, none of them has its head coach? No. This would suck. The committee’s wishy-washy, ever-changing rules and guidelines to make the playoffs have become so convoluted, so contradictory, that they require revision, AGAIN. Last year, the problem was giving conference champions a first-round bye. Oregon and Georgia were the only two teams with a bye that deserved it. It essentially made for a second round that was all but guaranteed to go to the point-spread favorites (which didn’t happen in Georgia’s case). Luckily, they made the change to straight seeding, assuming that would create more interesting, competitive games in each round of the playoffs. A few weeks ago, this looked to be going in a great direction. With Ohio State and Indiana separating themselves from the pack, and Georgia/Alabama all but guaranteed a bye should they win the SEC, and Texas Tech, given their margin of victory over their competition, gets a bye as well, it would’ve created matchups that look like this:
- G5 Representaive @ Oregon
- Miami/BYU/Utah/Vanderbilt @ Texas A&M
- Alabama @ Ole Miss
- Notre Dame @ Oklahoma
That’s already an improvement, but since the ACC ruined it, it must be better. It must be altered. For a sport that’s largely run by TV networks and measures its success on ratings, I’m shocked they’re still privy to and tied to this notion of conference champions, the coddling of the G5. I love G5 football. Tuesday night MACtion is my MNF, but are we really going to continue this ignorant megrim that those teams are playing the same sport as the power four teams? Do you expect me to believe that Tulane belongs on the same field as Ohio State? That they’re playing for the same title? Of course not, it’s fatuous. There’s a simple, fun solution to this: Give the G5 their own playoffs! An all-on-campus G5 playoff would be amazing for the players, fans, the towns they inhabit, and the greedy networks airing it. I would watch the shit out of that. Considering bowl games are all but dead, this serves as a great opportunity to keep college football relevant after the regular season, something the sport has been struggling to do since the BCS era. Instead of the Myrtle Beach Bowl or the Famous Idaho Potato Bowl, we would watch UNLV host MAC conference champions Western Michigan in the first round, followed by UConn vs. Kennesaw State. These teams have had good seasons, a few much better than others, but still, at least give the MAC champion a chance to compete for a title. If we had a separate playoff for the G5, the main playoff bracket would be filled with bangers. In fact, just remove the conference champion autobid altogether. If the ACC champion is won by a 7-5 team, then maybe the ACC shouldn’t be represented at all, and if they are, they should probably be represented by the team that has the best SOR in the conference, Miami (but that’s a separate, messier conversation about conferences becoming too large). Imagine this:
- (12) Texas @ (5) Oregon (to play Ohio State)
- (11) Alabama @ (6) Texas A&M (to play Georgia)
- (10) Notre Dame @ (7) Ole Miss (to play Indiana)
- (9) Miami (8) Oklahoma (to play Texas Tech)
Now, that’s a fuckin’ playoff. The teams I selected are purely based on speculation; a vast number of teams could make it, and each matchup would be fun and exciting. I don’t see a single blowout game in that hypothetical first round. Shit, you could see Miami travel to Oregon, Mario Cristobal taking on his former team would be awesome. We could see a Red River Shootout played on a home campus for the first time. Maybe even Utah could play Oregon for an old PAC-12-style game. It would be so much fun! But right now, we’re here. We’re seriously having to contemplate a world in which half of the first round are borderline unwatchable games that will be over by halftime if the road team is lucky. This is the rare time I will argue that the TV network overlords should do the greedy thing and give us two playoffs.