SEC PLAYOFF APOCOLYPSE

By Michael Alvord · · How we write and fact-check

HOW SEVEN SEC TEAMS COULD MAKE THE PLAYOFFS

Perfect Scenario for the SEC?

Oklahoma beat Alabama. Add the Crimson Tide to the list of 2-loss SEC teams, all of whom have a very decent case to get into the playoffs. Oklahoma’s win jolted them into the playoff discussion. Texas’ loss likely ended their chances, leaving Vanderbilt in a favorable position to make the playoffs. By my estimation, there are seven SEC teams still mathematically alive for the playoffs. I see worlds unknown to keen eyes. Worlds in which more than six SEC teams make the playoffs. I see… the dreams… of… Greg Sankey.

Scenario One: 5 SEC Teams

Three SEC teams are total locks right now. Texas A&M, even with a loss to Texas, is in. Georgia, should they finish 10-2, is in. And Ole Miss is guaranteed a spot, though, that’s with a little more assumption than the other two. Assuming they beat Mississippi State, they’re in. With that being said, is there room for two more? With Oklahoma’s win over Alabama, the Sooners are in great shape to earn a playoff spot after winning out. Assume the Sooners beat Missouri and LSU, both at home. Sooners finish 10-2. Alabama beats Auburn on the road and finishes 10-2, likely earning a spot in the SEC title game. Should Bama lose the SEC championship and finish with three losses, are they in? Yeah. Sorry, but a three-loss Alabama team with four ranked wins has a better resume than Notre Dame. They’re in. Oklahoma has the head-to-head win over the Tide, so they have to be in. That leaves the playoff field looking something along the lines of this: Ohio State, Indiana, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, Georgia, Big Ten team, Ole Miss, Oklahoma, Alabama, ACC Champion, Notre Dame, G5 Representative. Oklahoma beating Alabama was the best thing to happen to the SEC. Alabama, should they beat Auburn, has too good a resume to be left out. Their strength of record would trump that of a possible 11-2 BYU, or 10-2 Utah, 10-3 Virginia, 10-2 Georgia Tech, Notre Dame, Miami, even Oregon or a 10-2 USC should they win-out (the 6th spot is reserved for the winner of that game, should it be USC Notre Dame would get a massive boost).

This scenario does lack Big Ten teams, I’ll admit. Here’s how things across the country have to shake out, with the aforementioned SEC hypotheticals baked into this, for 5 SEC teams to make the playoffs: Ohio State wins out, thus knocking off Michigan for good. Indiana wins out. The SEC does not need an 11-1 Indiana competing for an at-large bid with the likes of Oklahoma and Alabama. Oregon wins out, thus removing USC as a playoff threat. And, in the Big 12, Texas Tech blows the doors out of BYU in the conference championship. I disagree with the notion that an 11-2 BYU team should be left out of the playoffs; however, an 11-2 BYU with two blowout losses to the only playoff-caliber team they will have played will not scale with the multiple ranked-wins-teams of the SEC. BYU would be competing with a possible 10-2 Vanderbilt, 9-3 Texas, or a 9-3 Tennessee before they would sniff an argument against a 10-2 Bama or Oklahoma. As for the ACC, things just need to continue how they are. If the odds play out, Georgia Tech will win the conference with an 11-2 record (assuming a loss to Georgia). They’re in. Since Miami is basically mathematically eliminated from competing in the ACC title, and the ACC is a bad conference, as stated by the committee itself, they shouldn’t be in. Blowing a load against SMU ended Miami’s playoff chances. Not making the conference title when teams like Virginia are all but guaranteed a spot despite losses to NC State and Wake Forest is embarrassing for any should-be ACC contender. They beat Notre Dame, but couldn’t win the lay-up that is the ACC. In a perfect world, Notre Dame doesn’t make the playoffs either. But we don’t live in a perfect world. Anyway, should ALL that happen, and it’s not unlikely, the SEC will have five teams in the playoffs. Congratulations.

Scenario Two: 6 SEC Teams - Hell on Earth

13-0 Texas A&M, 10-3 Alabama, 11-1 Georgia, 11-1 Ole Miss, 10-2 Oklahoma, 10-2 Vanderbilt. Honestly, the SEC championship game doesn’t really matter (if it’s between Alabama and Texas A&M), so long as Alabama doesn’t get beat by 90 in Atlanta. What this really comes down to, outside of all those SEC teams winning out, is the ACC, the Big 12, and Notre Dame.

So, in this six-team playoff scenario, the rankings would have to look something like this:

  1. Ohio State 13-0
  2. Texas A&M 13-0
  3. Indiana 12-1
  4. Texas Tech 12-1
  5. Georgia 11-1
  6. Ole Miss 11-1
  7. Oregon 11-1
  8. Oklahoma 10-2
  9. Alabama 10-3 went to Atlanta
  10. Georgia Tech 11-2
  11. Vanderbilt 10-2
  12. Group of Five Representative (James Madison 12-1)

So, essentially, what we’re looking at here is a doomsday scenario for Notre Dame. Should the playoffs look like this, BYU needn’t do anything more than lose the conference title, or lose any of their following games, for Vanderbilt to catapult their way to a playoff spot. Notre Dame can finish 10-2 in this scenario. If Miami loses any game and finishes 9-3, and the playoff committee isn't lying about taking strength of record into account for playoff seeding, Vanderbilt will have a better strength of record than Notre Dame if they beat Kentucky and Tennessee to finish 10-2. It’s the truth. Utah losing a game to finish 9-3 wouldn’t hurt either, though I imagine the committee will look at the SEC logo on Vanderbilt's jersey and compare 10-2 records and throw the Commodores over them. This won’t happen, at least it’s not likely. Notre Dame is very likely getting into the playoffs; should that be fair or not, I don’t know. Should there be a discussion about a 10-2 Vanderbilt battling Notre Dame for a spot, the most interesting aspect of that whole can’a worms would be who the country, notably SEC haters, side with in that scenario. Would the public be okay with the SEC owning half the field if it meant casting Notre Dame astray? It doesn’t hurt that it’s Vanderbilt, a likable team, and not a Tennessee or Texas. But, yeah, this is how six SEC teams could make the playoffs.

Scenario Three: 7 SEC Teams - An Apocalyptic Demise

Yo, I do not want this to happen. I don’t want six SEC teams in either, although should it come between Vanderbilt and Notre Dame, I vote Tulane. Hell, even the likely concept of five teams making the playoffs doesn’t fill me with glee, but should five SEC teams be among the most deserving 12 teams in the country, so be it. But, seven? Seven? How could this be?

11-2 Alabama, 11-2 Georgia, 11-1 Texas A&M, 11-1 Ole Miss, 10-2 Oklahoma, 10-2 Vanderbilt, 9-3 Texas. Okay, so, for this to happen, obviously, Texas needs to beat Texas A&M. That would pit the SEC title game between Alabama and Georgia. It doesn’t matter who wins; they’re both in. What’s fascinating is, if Georgia Tech beats Georgia, shocking as that would be, it wouldn’t matter, so long as Texas A&M loses that same night. Georgia, competing for an SEC title, with a head-to-head over Ole Miss, Texas, and maybe Alabama, would get in as would an ACC-champion, 12-1, Georgia Tech. How would Texas get in over the likes of BYU, Notre Dame, Utah, Virginia, or any 9-3 Big Ten team? Texas would have three wins over three teams that will likely be ranked above them in this hypothetical playoff poll. 3-1 total against the playoff field, possessing wins over Oklahoma, Texas A&M, and Vanderbilt. Since we’ve already demonstrated how Vanderbilt would be over Notre Dame, we need to assume the same logic applies to Texas. Meaning, yes, Miami still needs to finish 9-3. To put this out chronologically, Oregon loses to USC, USC loses to UCLA, Texas beats Texas A&M, Miami loses a game, thus tanking Notre Dame's strength of record, holding no significant wins to scale with the teams above, plus a head-to-head loss to Texas A&M- just for good measure. Alabama needs to win out, Oklahoma needs to win out, and Vanderbilt needs to win out. Alabama and Georgia will play for the SEC title game, and both will get in. Texas Tech blows the doors off BYU once again, Ohio State and Indiana win out, and all are in. Georgia Tech wins the ACC. Obviously, if Notre Dame loses a game, that too would help. Thus, we’d have a playoff field that looks like this:

  1. Ohio State 13-0
  2. Indiana 12-1
  3. Texas Tech 12-1
  4. Alabama 11-2
  5. Texas A&M 11-1
  6. Georgia 11-2
  7. Ole Miss 11-1
  8. Oklahoma 10-2
  9. Georgia Tech 11-2
  10. Vanderbilt 10-2
  11. JMU 12-1
  12. Texas 9-3

Oregon would be on the outside looking in IF the committee takes the strength of record as the ultimate comparison when records are similar. Thankfully, this is unlikely. Very unlikely. If this did happen, I imagine they would change the rules in the offseason - again - and eliminate the Group of Five autobid, as to never let a 10-2 Notre Dame or Oregon out ever again.