How Seven Teams Can Win the ACC - Tiebreakers and Mania on the East Coast
By Michael Alvord · · How we write and fact-check
The ACC championship picture is a complete mess. Mostly due to ineptitude at the conference front-offices. Of these seven contenders who will make the conference title game?
The SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12 all seem to have pretty straightforward conference-title races right now. Bama and A&M hold sole possession of the SEC, for now. The Big 12 seems to be in complete control of BYU and Texas Tech, and the Big Ten is heading for a collision course between Ohio State and Indiana. The ACC, however, is a muddy picture. Duke is currently the odds-on favorite to win the conference. So, that’s crazy. Virginia is in first right now with an undefeated conference record, despite losing to NC State, which did not count as a conference game because the ACC is managed fairly horribly compared to the other power conferences. Georgia Tech, Pitt, Louisville, SMU, and Duke are all tied for second with just one conference loss. Georgia Tech is coming off a loss to NC State, ruining their undefeated season, and Miami got knocked off by SMU, likely ending their playoff chances. Miami now sits behind six teams in its conference standings. Due to the size of the ACC, many of these contenders don’t get to play each other, leading to some pretty bizarre tie-breaker situations. For example, suppose Georgia Tech wins the rest of their ACC games, and Virginia drops one to, let’s just say Duke, and Louisville wins out. In that case, the ACC title game will be between Virginia and Louisville, leaving a 10-2 (loss to SEC’s UGA) Georgia Tech at home. And that opens up a litany of questions regarding these teams' respective playoff chances. If Georgia Tech loses to Georgia and does not play for the ACC title despite just one conference loss, are they out? Or do you put Georgia Tech in and leave the loser of the ACC championship out? If you did that, then the team that played in the ACC championship got screwed over via tiebreakers because it’s very likely that if they never played in the conference title game, they’d have a better chance to make the playoffs. But, of these contenders, who is actually going to make a run?
Virginia 8-1 (5-0 ACC)
Sitting atop the conference right now are the Virginia Cavaliers, led by head coach Tony Elliott. Virginia is currently favored by 6.5 this weekend against Wake Forest, then they travel to Duke, and then host Virginia Tech in their annual rivalry after a bye week. Virginia will likely be favored in 2 of those three games. On the road at Duke is a scary spot, and it seems like Vegas considers the Blue Devils more of a threat than Virginia right now, and I agree. Virginia has had the easiest strength of schedule in the conference and is coming off five close games. Assuming they can get through Wake Forest, which isn’t a guarantee, then they would be due for a loss at Duke. Duke will be coming off a road win (I’m assuming a win) against UConn before they host the Hoo’s. I don’t think the public is quite ready or prepared for an 11-1 Virginia team. I don’t even think Elliott or the players are ready either. That being said, it is very likely that Virginia finishes 10-2 or 11-1, barring unforeseen losses to weaker teams in Wake and Tech. In the case of a 10-2 Virginia with one conference loss, they would not be guaranteed a spot in the ACC title game. In the events of each point-spread favorite winning out in the ACC, Duke and Georgia Tech would both finish ahead of Virginia in the standings. Virginia can lock a spot in the ACC title game if they win their next three games, obviously, but a loss could legit kill their season if they don’t get help elsewhere in the conference. Should Virginia finish the rest of their games 2-1 with a loss to Duke, they can only make a conference championship appearance if Georgia Tech loses another conference game, likely on the road at Pitt, and Louisville loses another conference game as well, either to Clemson or SMU, all of which wouldn’t be shocking. If Virginia wins out, this is all a moot point, but considering how compact this conference is, I wouldn’t bet on that.
Georgia Tech 8-1 (5-1 ACC)
Georgia Tech has two remaining conference games left on its schedule. They play an awful Boston College team and then host Pitt. That Pitt game is their Super Bowl. For the purposes of this study, their last game against the Georgia Bulldogs won’t have any merit in this discussion. A loss to the Bulldogs will affect their playoff chances, but it’s imperative for them to get through the rest of their conference games first. Off the rip, if they lose to Boston College, the season is mathematically over. That very likely isn’t going to happen, though, so all eyes rest on Tech’s matchup against the Pittsburgh Panthers. A loss to Pitt ends their chances completely as well. In every scenario in which Georgia Tech loses to Pitt, they don’t make the conference title. Beat Pitt and they make the title 75% of the time. The only way the Yellow Jackets make the ACC title game with a loss to Pitt is: Louisville loses @ Cal and @ Clemson, Virginia loses to Wake Forest and Virginia Tech, Miami loses another game and beats Pitt, Duke loses to Virginia and Wake Forest, and SMU loses to Louisville. That would make the ACC title game Georgia Tech vs Virginia, both with 2 conference losses, likely three total losses. Georgia Tech is still at risk of not making the ACC title game with a win against Pitt if Louisville wins out as well.
Louisville 7-1 (4-1 ACC)
Louisville finds itself in a great spot to compete for an ACC title. If Louisville wins out, they are in no matter what. Louisville would get the nod over Georgia Tech and face the winner of the Duke/Virginia game. Louisville has played a tougher schedule than Georgia Tech, so despite having the same record, Louisville would jump Tech in the standings because their opponents' win percentage would trump Tech's (.500 for Louisville, .375 for Tech). Louisville does play the toughest schedule to finish out the season, though. Not including hosting Kentucky from the SEC, the Cards have to host a feisty Cal team, Clemson (who will be in a revenge spot and be fighting for bowl eligibility), and go to SMU. If they win out, they would likely be the favorite in the ACC title game, even if it’s against Virginia, whom they lost to a few weeks ago. The ACC isn’t a great conference, but that’s the hardest stretch of in-conference games you’ll see out of any of these contenders. Louisville will have earned it. And, just a little caveat, Louisville has a win over 7-1 JMU, who, in my opinion, should be the G5 front-runners for that playoff spot. Just something to keep in mind.
SMU 6-3 (4-1 ACC)
SMU has a pretty decent ride to the ACC Championship game, if winning out were the only thing they needed to do. They’ll have to travel to Boston College, a game they should win fairly easily, then host Louisville after a bye, and finish the season at Cal. Making the championship game, however, is a different story. Outside of winning out, SMU needs Georgia Tech to lose another conference game, and they need Virginia to win out. Since SMU plays Louisville, they can knock them out themselves, but they need help from others to stay alive for postseason ball. In fairness to all the one-loss contenders in the ACC, SMU is one of the least believable teams. They’re not very consistent, but they’re good at home, and they do host their last two hardest games. If this SMU team were to somehow make a run, they would be one of the least deserving playoff teams ever. They have two losses to mid-tier Big 12 teams and a loss to a bad Wake Forest team. If I’m the ACC comish, I’m rooting against SMU. They’d kill the conference's chances of having more than one bid in the playoffs.
Duke 5-3 (4-1 ACC)
If Duke wins out, they’ll be in the ACC title game, and they’ll be favored in the rest of their games. That’s why they’re currently the odds-on favorite to win the ACC. Duke’s only conference loss is at the hands of Georgia Tech. Assuming they win out as well, that would set up a rematch between the two in Charlotte. Duke’s remaining schedule is quite favorable. They travel to UConn (OOC), host Virginia, travel to UNC, and finish the season hosting Wake Forest. They never leave the state for the last three weeks of the season, and if they win out, they still won’t have to leave the state for the ACC title game. Much like SMU, Duke has two losses to out-of-conference (OOC) opponents, those being against Illinois and on the road against Tulane. Similar to SMU, this Duke team is completely undeserving of any postseason relevance, but since everyone who is actually a competitor in the ACC this year does not play each other, we are once again in a predicament where the ACC’s champion isn’t the best team, but the team given the most favorable schedule (i.e., last year’s Clemson team).
Pitt 7-2 (5-1 ACC)
Pitt has just been cruising along unnoticed this season since their loss to West Virginia in Week Three and their loss to Louisville in the very next game. Notice how there’s a theme of ACC title contenders losing to Big 12 teams. Anyway, since then, Pitt has rattled off five in a row to improve to 5-1 in the conference. This Saturday, Pitt is on bye before they host Notre Dame (OOC), head over to Atlanta to take on Tech, and then host Miami to end the season. They could very easily finish that stretch 0-3, but if they go 2-1, winning both conference games, Pitt can only make the conference title game if Virginia wins out and SMU defeats Louisville. Not as complex a run as SMU, or even really Georgia Tech, it’s just unfortunate for Pitt that they have such a tough road to get there. I think that Pitt will split the Miami and Georgia Tech games. Assuming it’s Georgia Tech, then Pitt will likely have done nothing more than end their season and catapult Louisville, Virginia, and Duke way up. There’s still hope in Pittsburgh, though, who will look to win their second ACC title under head coach Pat Narduzzi.
Miami 6-2 (2-2 ACC)
It’s really funny that the most talented, hyped up team in the ACC has the least likely chance of making a conference title run. After dropping a game to Louisville, a loss that I feel like is garnering a lot of disrespect toward Miami rather than admission of Louisville's legitimacy. But, after the Hurricanes' overtime loss in Dallas to SMU, there is nothing else to garner but disrespect toward the ‘Canes. I understand that Kevin Jennings is a great quarterback, and Rhett Lashlee is a great head coach, and it was the biggest home game at SMU since they were dominating in the SWC in the 80s, but I don’t care. SMU’s pass defense is so bad, and Miami has great receivers and a good offensive line. Their $4M quarterback is what held them back twice now this season. Assuming Miami at its best is easily the best team in the conference, then the likelihood of them winning out is actually quite high, which would leave Miami with a 10-2 finish with a win over Notre Dame, still a better resume than last year and the same record, though last year, two conference losses left them out of the playoffs. Could we see that happen again? Because it’s almost guaranteed that even if Miami were to win out, they wouldn’t even sniff the ACC title game. For Miami to win the ACC, they need to firstly win out (no shit), then they need Louisville to lose two games, likely against Clemson and SMU. They need SMU to lose one more game, either to Cal or Boston College. They also need Virginia to win out, and finally, they need Georgia Tech to lose to Pitt. If all those things happen, Miami will play Virginia in the ACC title game with a 10-2 record. Good friggin’ luck.
Verdict
It seems like Virginia, Duke, Louisville, and Georgia Tech have a little separation from the rest of the contenders. Miami is in a peculiar spot. Should they finish 10-2 with a win over Notre Dame, then Miami could very easily claim a playoff spot, but would that playoff spot be bumping a potential 10-win ACC title game loser out of the playoffs? And is that fair? Miami sits at home, and, let's say, 11-2 Virginia with an ACC championship loss stays home? In every scenario, someone in the ACC is getting screwed. There’s no way around that, and it’s the ACC’s fault too. In what world do you have a 17-team league, and only 8-conference games? Not to mention not protecting key rivalries, and the travel being abhorrently stupid now. Virginia doesn’t play Georgia Tech, SMU, Miami, Pitt, or even Clemson. They’ve had the easiest schedule in the conference by far. Georgia Tech doesn’t play Louisville, SMU, Miami, Virginia, or Duke. I could go on and on, but my point is clearly illustrated. The way the ACC is run is detrimental to the league's success and legitimacy. I’m not a hater. I would love to see Virginia in the playoffs, but avoiding four contenders and backfilling that with close wins over conference bottom-feeders doesn’t scream “Conference Champion, playoff bound,” to me.
Now that we know who sits where and who plays who, I believe the most likely ACC championship game to be between Louisville and Duke. I don’t think Duke is very good, and Virginia beat Louisville, so I’d be much more interested in a rematch there, but as of right now, I’d take Georgia Tech to beat Pitt, Duke to beat Virginia, and Louisville to beat SMU, thus having a four-way tie for first place between UVA, GT, UL, and Duke. Louisville and Duke would get the nod to play in the conference championship based on opponent win percentage. The ACC is going to be a mess no matter what, and I can’t wait for certain fanbases to claim playoff legitimacy with only one, maybe zero, ranked wins (Virginia).