NCAA Winners and Losers of Week 8

By Michael Alvord · · How we write and fact-check

Huge shake-up in the Top-25 this week. Let's see who made it out alive, and who's on life alert.

Saturday was, as always, a massive week for college football. Miami lost, Texas Tech lost, Ole Miss lost, Tennessee lost, LSU lost, and that’s just what happened in the top-10. BYU proved their legitimacy as a playoff contender, Arizona State reentered the conversation with a massive win over Texas Tech, and Missouri kept their season alive whilst ending Hugh Freeze’s career. All that and more in this weeks Winners and Losers of Week 8.

Winners

Alabama

Bama won their fourth straight ranked conference win, and have taken care of two of their three revenge games. The Tide will be playing an unranked team in South Carolina this Saturday. Despite the Cocks putrid offensive identity, it’s still a huge let-down spot for the Tide. As of right now though, Alabama is the favorite to win the SEC.

Georgia

The Bulldogs continue to impress, especially offensively. The Bulldogs went down early again in this matchup, and yet again, the Dawgs held on and clawed their way back in the game to stay within the SEC championship conversation. Ole Miss proves that they’re a legit playoff contender in this game as well, but credit has to go to the mentality of this Georgia team, the moxie and poise of Gunner Stockton, and even the play calling from Mike Bobo.

Notre Dame

Welcome to the playoffs, Notre Dame! At the beginning of the season, when the Irish were 0-2, many thought shouldif they won out, they still wouldn’t make the playoffs because their strength of record wouldn’t warrant it. Well, now Notre Dame has a win over a sneaky, really good Boise State team and a legitimate top-25 team in USC. The only way Notre Dame doesn’t make the playoffs at 10-2 is if it comes between them and a 9-3 Texas A&M, but knowing what’s behind the decision-making of the committee (TV ratings), I’d bet my life that they’ll both make the playoffs given that scenario. If Notre Dame improves week over week, there’s no reason they can’t make another playoff run like they did last season.

Arizona State

The Sun Devils had a massive win over #7 Texas Tech. The Sun Devils were defensively on another level on Saturday. Tech’s backup quarterback, Will Hammond, looked completely lost, and the run game was shut down. The defense made sure that the freshman backup quarterback would struggle in his first road start. Sam Leavitt IS this team. There’s no reason Arizona State can’t win out, assuming Leavitt stays healthy and makes their way back to the college football playoffs.

Vanderbilt

Fellas. Vanderbilt is a legit top-10 team. I never thought I’d see the day, but here we are. Vanderbilt still has a bit of a schedule in front of them, but if they can play the way they did against LSU, this team could legitimately make it to Atlanta. They have a huge game this weekend as the Dores take on the Missouri Tigers in a top-15 matchup. After that, Vanderbilt has to get through Texas, Auburn, Kentucky, and Tennessee. If they can go 4-1 in that stretch, they’ll easily be in the playoffs. If they go undefeated, then you could easily see them in Atlanta.

BYU

BYU cemented themselves as the team to beat in the Big 12. Like many, I myself questioned BYU up until this game. I took Utah to win and cover. I actually thought it was the best bet last week. Obviously, that didn’t happen. Despite looking so clunky and off at times, this BYU team finds ways to win and now controls their destiny in the Big 12. Unfortunately for the Cougs, their remaining schedule is no joke. This Saturday, they’ll travel to Ames to face Iowa State. BYU is a slight underdog right now in that game, then on the road against Texas Tech, then TCU, then at Cincinnati, and they finish against UCF. Personally, I think they’ll lose at least two of those games, but we’ll see. They’ve proven me wrong before; I won’t be shocked if they prove me wrong again.

Losers

Memphis

The Tigers had an opportunity to host College GameDay, assuming they get out of the UAB game with a win. They’d essentially be playing for the group of five national title this Saturday against USF. Now they’re as dead as every other group of five teams. They lost to a team with an interim head coach with ZERO reason to have a motivated performance at any given point this season. Memphis can still beat USF, but given that outcome, I’d expect Navy to be the new group of five frontrunners for the playoffs.

Auburn

This is it. The Freeze on the Plains is done. Auburn loses another close, gut-wrenching, OVERTIME loss at home to Missouri. Missouri is a good football team; it’s a loss to take no shame in, but unfortunately, this game kind of catalyzes Hugh Freeze’s tenure at Auburn. I expect the Tigers to lose to Petrino’s Arkansas this Saturday, and come next Monday, be looking for a new head coach.

LSU - Bad Week to be a Tiger.

You could pretty much copy and paste the things I wrote about Freeze and put them here, but this result leaves LSU in a weird spot. They lost to the better team, but it’s unacceptable to have a worse team than 14 of 16 members in the SEC at LSU. They can’t run the ball. Kelly made a bad hire at offensive coordinator, plain and simple. Nussmeier is hurt, and they refuse to put in a different guy, either out of stubbornness and ignorance of Nussmeier’s health or a massive depth issue. If they don’t have anyone to back up Nussmiere, then you gotta ask yourself, “So we’re at best an 8-4 team this season, we should be a playoff team, what does the future with Kelly provide us?” Seriously, though, there’s no future there. It feels like a dead program. I expect the LSU job to come open this season as well. It’s gonna be wild.

Miami

You got to be shitting me. AGAIN?! Mario, what the hell are we doing?! You’ve built up the team to be BY FAR the most talented in the conference, you looked like a genuine national title contender, and when Twitter burners came at me and said “don’t buy into Miami, they’ll lose a game or two they’re not supposed to,” I defended you! And whaddya do? Lost to Louisville. In fairness, at least this game wasn’t decided by coaching malpractice (kinda) and a spotty defense; it came down to the quarterback. Miami is paying Carson Beck more money than god to play quarterback for them, and many judged that decision. The tape on Beck last season was bad. Full of poor decision-making and bad reads, but the year before that, Beck was amazing. Why the falloff? Georgia led the country last year in drops, so Miami took the risk, and they gave him great receivers and a great offensive line. For a while, it looked like the experiment went well, but then, on Friday night, he played a real defense, and he threw FOUR interceptions. I think Miami is still the best team in the ACC and should make the playoffs, but I would not be shocked if they failed once again. Nobody fears ‘The U.’

Texas Tech

You didn’t have a package ready for Hammond? And now you lose your tortilla toss tradition? It’s imperative for Texas Tech to get healthy as soon as possible, and refine the run game, or rather than refine, DEFINE what you want the run game to be, and what you need to do in case it’s not there. Morton is day-to-day, no news yet on Carter, Gil-Howard is out for the season, most likely. Did you spend all that money on your #1s only? You ain’t got depth? Luckily, Tech has a chance to prove itself when they host BYU in a few weeks. They’ve proven enough to me to still be my favorite to win the Big 12, but if injuries plague this team and there’s inconsistency on offense, Tech could play their way out of a conference championship entirely.