Winners and Losers of Week 5
By Michael Alvord · · How we write and fact-check
Week Five provided us with the best slate of football we've seen all season, but not everyone can be winners.
In the off-season, Week Five was looked at as the most anticipated slate of the season. The SEC had massive games featuring Ole Miss exposing the LSU Tigers, a Kentucky player assaulting Lenoris Sellers’ grandfather, Mississippi State proved to be no sleeper in the SEC and took Tennessee to overtime, where the Vols would eventually win, and for the main event, Alabama once again beat Georgia. Doesn’t matter if it’s Tuscaloosa, Atlanta, or Athens; Bama will beat Georgia. In the Big Ten, Ohio State continues to impress with a convincing win against a good Washington team in Seattle. The Buckeyes' defense hasn’t missed a beat with the departure of Jim Knowles and a significant roster churn. In fact, Matt Patricia is the best defensive coordinator in the country right now. Iowa proved to be a tough place to play in, but ultimately came short against a damn good Indiana team. I’ve seen a lot of people on social media look at this performance and think less of Indiana, but seeing them in a close game and finish it out the way they did just improves my confidence in their ability to beat one of the big boys, the likes of Oregon, Ohio State, etc. Illinois bounced back after a 53-point loss to beat USC with a game-winning field goal in a great game. Later that night, Dante Moore, Dan Lanning, and the Oregon Ducks dragged their nuts all over the Nittany Lions during the White-Out. Dante Moore was a bit overlooked in the off-season because people straight-up didn’t watch his freshman season as the starter for Chip Kelly’s UCLA Bruins. We underestimated the value of having a quarterback with a full season of starting experience to then sit a year and learn under Dylan Gabriel, and it’ll likely result in a third straight Heisman finalist appearance from an Oregon Quarterback. It’s also time to have yet another tough conversation about Lincoln Riley and James Franklin. As mentioned on Boozin’ Friday Ball, Arizona State beat TCU in a Big Twelve thriller, which was then matched by another great game in Cincinnati's win over Kansas. Also mentioned was Florida State’s loss in Charlottesville to the Hoo’s. Georgia Tech stole a win from Wake Forest in an overtime game in Winston-Salem. We’ll further discuss all that and more in my Week Five Winners and Losers segment!
Winners
Alabama: Some Things Never Change.
Alabama 24 - Georgia 21 For the second straight year, Kalen Deboer and company had Kirby Smart’s staff in hell during the first half of the game. Bama was perfect on their first eight third-down attempts, something you never see out of a Kirby Smart defense. Ty Simpson cemented his name in stone, and not to spoil the Week Five MVPs, but Simpson will be the unanimous #1 MVP of the week. Not to sound like Cris Collinsworth, but here’s a guy who waited his turn to be the starter at Alabama when he could’ve transferred and started almost anywhere else in the country. Here’s a guy who stuck around the brand following the departure of Nick Saban. Here’s a guy who heard all that noise following the Florida State game and walked into Athens with a chip on his shoulder and, like all the great Bama quarterbacks before him, shredded the Georgia Bulldogs. Simpson threw for 276 yards, completing 63% of his passes, and threw 2 touchdowns, while also recording a rushing score on top of that. Other MVPs for this game were both coordinators for the Tide. Ryan Grubb called a lot of plays that would’ve made Nick Saban towel whip Lane Kiffin, but totally fooled Kirby Smart and Glenn Schumann. The Tide did not rely on Ryan Williams to carry the load on the receiving end. 9 Alabama receivers caught passes Saturday night, averaging 11.2 yards per reception as a team, including an 11-yard screen pass to left tackle, Kadyn Proctor, a play that, at least to me, and despite the Dawgs' effort to claw back, was the nail in the coffin for Georgia’s defense. Just a wicked play that would leave me absolutely sick if I were a Georgia fan. Defensively, Kane Wommack finally coached a squad to bring pressure on the line of scrimmage, and the secondary, as always this season, was also near perfect. The run defense still leaves something to be desired, but damn, how can you not be bullish on the Tide?
Oregon & Dan Lanning Discussion: What is Lanning On?
Oregon 30 - Penn State 24 - 2OT Unfortunately, I have less to say about Oregon’s win than I do Penn State’s loss, but that being said, there is a lot to discuss and analyze about Oregon’s performance in Happy Valley during the all-feared White-Out game. Let’s start with the Ducks Quarterback, Dante Moore, who blew up the Jim Knowles-led Nittany Lion defense for 248 passing yards and 3 touchdowns. Moore completed an impressive 75% of his passes while completing two passes or more to seven of his receivers, a bulk of which went to both True Freshman Dakorien Moore (no relation to Dante Moore) and Senior Gary Bryant Jr., combining for 13 catches, 144 yards, and a touchdown. Penn State led a worthy effort in the fourth quarter to make the game entertaining, but despite them even taking the lead at one point, at no time did I think Oregon would lose the game. Congrats on the big win, Ducks! Onto Dan Lanning… I love the guy; he’s a great coach and a perfect fit for the Oregon Ducks, and like, hey, I’ve been around the block a few times, I’m an old dog (in dog years), I get it, but if you’re going to do cocaine throughout the game, don’t make it super obvious during the post-game interview. Glazers called you a “maniac” (complimentary), but ball knowers saw right through that. Either Dan Lanning has a snuff bullet behind his clipboard, or he popped like six adderall. I mean, as far as I know, Oregon hasn’t released any statement or complaints about how he conducted himself on-screen. So, as an American, and I’m not condoning drug use, but the concept of not only getting away with looking like a coked-out maniac on national television, while representing an AAU university, and getting praised for it is kinda the most badass thing ever.
Ole Miss: Great Win, Probably Not the Best Time to Play ‘Neck’ Though.
LSU 19 - Ole Miss 24 Saturday might as well have been Father's Day, the way Lane Kiffin put an ass-whoopin’ on his daughter's boyfriend, (LSU linebacker) Whitt Weeks. Brotha was throwing up on the field! While he was defending the Kiffin name, he also exposed LSU for who I suspected they might be following Clemson’s collapse. It’s not fair to compare a team to their week one opponent, especially if you beat them on the road, because most of the time it’s not reflective of what the team actually is, but in this case, Clemson ended up being frauds, and thus, LSU’s best win, earning them a top-5 spot, was also fraudulent. Kiffin and his backup quarterback, Trinidad Chambliss, blew up an admittedly much-improved secondary for 314 yards and a touchdown. The most impressive part, the Rebels' defense was giving up about 5 yards per rush leading up to Saturday. LSU has had trouble offensively, but you’d think, given their talent, they’d be able to expose the Rebs' run defense and cruise to a win. Nope. Ole Miss held the Tigers to 59 rushing yards on 21 attempts, and it wasn’t for the Tigers’ lack of trying. They were nearly a 50/50 split run/pass on Saturday. Ole Miss dominated them. They beat them worse than the final score indicates, in my professional opinion. Ole Miss may be overranked in the AP poll, and even my own Pearl Poll, but if you watched the game with your own eyes, which the AP poll voters don’t do, you’d see a complete team in Ole Miss.
Ohio State: Total Reload
Ohio State 24 - Washington 6 Ohio State was on upset alert this week, and for good reason. Washington had the second-longest home winning streak in the country with 22 straight wins. Husky Stadium is a tough place to play in. This was Julian Sayin’s first road start, and the “traveling two time zones for a conference game curse” applied to Ohio State. None of it mattered. Ohio State’s defense is unbelievable, recording 6 sacks and not allowing a single touchdown. The offense was a bit slow to start, reasonable for Sayin’s first road start, but it started rolling after the first quarter. Washington was unranked for some odd reason before this game, so it went overlooked to the mass public, but mark my words, this win will look so impressive in November, and if I’m wrong, it’s because Jedd Fisch is leaving for Florida and the Huskies fall apart.
Dr. Steven Shin: Mateer Miracle Worker
John Mateer injured his hand in last week's win against Auburn and was reported to be sidelined for several weeks. Oklahoma’s schedule following the injury includes a bye, Kent State, and the Red River Shootout, and it seemed Mateer would not be back for the anticipated game against the Longhorns, which was devastating news for Sooners fans. But then, a shining bright light from Los Angeles appeared. An Angel, from the West Coast, kinda like Mateer himself, hand surgeon, Dr. Steven Shin. Dr. Shin operated on Mateer, and it went successfully, and the staff at Normal anticipate a faster recovery than prior thought. Following the surgery, OU entered its bye, and is now gearing up for a game against Kent State. The Sooners will be starting backup quarterback Michael Hawkins Jr., who got a lot of meaningful playing time last season. Not to mention, Kent State might be the worst team in FBS football. We severely hope Mateer will be back to play the Texas Loghorns.
MVPs
- Alabama QB - Ty Simpson, 24/38, 276 YDS, 2 TD, 1 RSH TD
- Oregon QB - Dante Moore, 29/39, 248 YDS, 3TD
- Illinois QB - Luke Altmyer, 20/26, 328 YDS, 2 TD, 1 RSH TD
- Cincinnati QB - Brendan Sorsby, 29/43, 388 YDS, 2 TD
- Memphis RB - Greg Desrosiers Jr., 19 CAR, 204 YDS, 3 TD
Losers
Officiating During Georgia Tech @ Wake Forest Game
Georgia Tech 30 - Wake Forest 29 - OT Here’s the dilemma: Wake Forest has the ball, leading 23-20, it’s 3rd and 5 with 1:52 left in regulation. On this now infamous play, a Georgia Tech player clearly leaps offside, giving Robby Ashford a free play, so he thought. Naturally, he heaves it deep, and the pass is incomplete, but then, somehow, it was fourth down. The ref blatantly missed the call and forced Wake Forest to punt. They’d later go on to lose the game in overtime. The ACC later admitted to the missed call, and that’s that. Coaches and players are held accountable for criticizing officiating, but when the officiating is wrong and ends up deciding a game, the officials aren’t held accountable at all. They go back to their day jobs and referee another game the next week. It’s ludicrous. College Football is a billion-dollar industry, up there with the likes of the NFL, and there are no standardized rules for officiating across conferences. That’s big loser energy.
Lincoln Riley & James Franklin
It’s been almost ten years since James Franklin beat a top-five team. Typically, I give Franklin the benefit of the doubt as he’s typically the underdog and lacks the depth of the teams he’s facing, like Ohio State or Michigan. But all reports and expectations out of State College screamed that this was the year. Penn State will win the Big Ten, and they’ll split the Ohio State Oregon games! Penn State entered the game as a 3.5-point favorite; they avoided the Big Noon kickoff and finally got a huge opponent for the White-Out. And they still lost. Offensively, it really doesn’t matter how many wide-outs you get in the portal; returning a quarterback for his third starting season doesn’t matter either. Penn State is completely offensively inept in big games. I’m aware Drew Allar was able to turn on the jets and lead a comeback in the fourth quarter, but it was too little too late. This was the White-Out. This was your Super Bowl, and for three quarters, Allar didn’t do squat. That matters! Hiring Jim Knowles didn’t matter; returning production in the secondary doesn’t matter. It all doesn’t matter because James Franklin can’t win the big game. I want him to, I really do, but it’s just insane to me how dead Penn State always looks offensively in big games and constantly relies on the opponents' mistakes to stay in games. Franklin has the chance to prove himself again in back-to-back games against Ohio State and Indiana in early November, but I wouldn’t count on it.
As for Lincoln Riley, I really don’t know what to say. At least you didn’t lose at home to a coke-head maniac, but you did lose to a team that got smashed by 53 last week. The Trojans prove once again that they’re not ready to compete with the big boys. They’re on Nebraska status, and that’s not the expectation at Southern Cal. Blue Bloods are all starting to become competitive at the same time again because of NIL, and the Trojans are just not participating. At least, not participating enough. I believe USC has a problem at the administrative level when it comes to how to handle the football program in this new era, but Riley hasn’t done himself any favors either. Riley’s season isn’t over, and his job is far from gone, but he has to start winning some Big Ten road games. If Oregon can adjust, so can you.
Peacock
Please don’t make me log in to my ex’s Peacock to access Indiana vs Iowa or any college football game ever again. I was able to get in, luckily, but not before sending several confirmation emails. Meaning, during my college football Saturday, I got a text from the last person I wanna hear from. Thanks a lot, NBC. We used to be able to tune into the Big Ten network or ESPN U for that content, but now it’s behind a paywall and seven ads for The Office revival.